Skip to main content
← All case studies

Ohio · Foundational literacy · 2023–24

A closer look at
early reading.

From the sounds in a word to the meaning in a story. Ohio’s first statewide tutoring year offers a closer look at foundational literacy, the instruction behind it, and the progress students showed.

Learners
343 students · Grades K–5
School settings
13 schools · 10 districts
Delivery
Live virtual small-group tutoring
Program window
2023–24 · Local schedules varied

Inside the instruction

From sounds.
To words. To meaning.

The program connected systematic phonics instruction with decodable reading and checks for understanding. Students began at an instructional starting point informed by assessment.

01

Find the starting point.

The Phonics Hero Placement Test helped identify each student’s instructional reading level and where to begin.

02

Work on the sounds.

Phonics Hero lessons and Cignition resources supported explicit work on letter–sound relationships, blending, and reading fluency.

03

Put the skills into a story.

Decodable texts gave students opportunities to apply the phonics skills they were learning in connected reading.

04

Check the understanding.

Embedded mastery checks helped tutors revisit skills and guide work on comprehension, text evidence, and explanations.

A small group. A regular routine. Sessions ran for 30–35 minutes, two to five times per week, depending on the local program. The average student-to-tutor ratio was 3.1:1.

Explore our instructional approach

Reading progress

Read the progress.
Keep the time in view.

The source report groups reading growth by tutoring contact hours. These are different groups of students, with different school and learning contexts.

Across participating students

0.41

Months of reading growth per tutoring hour, on average.

A separate view of the program’s reading-growth measure. Individual rates varied; this is not a forecast for a future student.

Planned and delivered

The program set a 50-hour school-year goal. Students received 25.1 hours on average, with start dates and local logistics affecting the time available.

Average reading growth by contact hours

Program-aligned reading growth, in months

05101520
40–50 hours
17.8
30–40 hours
15.1
20–30 hours
10.9
10–20 hours
6.5
0–10 hours
2.5

Each row shows the average for that contact-hour group. School instruction continued alongside tutoring.

The 17.8-month result belongs to the 40–50-hour group. Differences between groups do not establish that tutoring hours alone caused the outcomes.

Participation & experience

Showing up.
Taking part. Looking ahead.

Attendance and student feedback add two distinct views of the implementation: whether students were there, and how they described the learning experience.

Time together

89.5%

Average student attendance.

Across scheduled foundational-literacy sessions. 95% of students met or exceeded the program’s 70% attendance benchmark.

Consistent session times and school contacts helped support the tutoring routine.

In students’ responses

92.6%

Positive survey responses.

Students answered questions about their tutor, collaboration, understanding, and persistence. Positive responses included “Strongly Agree” and “Somewhat Agree.”

This describes survey responses. Separately, 74.9% of students met the program’s 90% survey-positivity benchmark.

More than one growth story

The average is a start.
The range matters, too.

The report set a target of 0.48 months of reading growth per contact hour. 41.7% of students reached or exceeded it. Other students progressed at different rates.

Reading development, starting skills, school context, and how engagement is measured all matter when interpreting an individual result.

How reading-growth rates varied.

Share of students in each rate band

Months of program-aligned reading growth per contact hour
Growth rateVisual share of studentsStudents
0.48 or more41.7%
0.40–0.4716.5%
0.30–0.3914.2%
0.20–0.2915.0%
Below 0.2012.6%
The five reported groups total 100% of students.

Read the evidence

A useful result.
A clear definition.

Explore how the program measured reading progress, who the headline result describes, and what the report can—and cannot—tell us.

View the broader Ohio program
What does “months of reading growth” mean?

The program tracked movement through a phonics-based sequence with 26 reading levels. The report treats advancement through approximately 6–7 levels as one year of reading growth and expresses that progress in months. It is a program-aligned estimate, rather than a state-test result or a stand-alone measure of grade-level proficiency.

Who does the 17.8-month result describe?

It describes students who received 40–50 tutoring contact hours during the 2023–24 Ohio foundational-literacy implementation, alongside their schools’ core instruction. It is not the average for all participating students, a companywide result, or a prediction of what another student will achieve.

How does 0.41 months per hour differ?

The report gives an average reading-growth rate of 0.41 months per tutoring contact hour across students. That rate answers a different question from the 17.8-month average for the 40–50-hour subgroup. It should not be used as a formula to promise future growth from a set number of tutoring hours.

How were attendance and survey results measured?

Attendance is the share of scheduled sessions students attended. The 92.6% figure is the share of student survey responses that were positive—“Strongly Agree” or “Somewhat Agree”—across questions about tutor relationships, collaboration, understanding, and persistence. Those responses describe students’ reported experience, rather than an academic assessment.

What should readers keep in mind?

Students participated in different school settings and received different amounts of tutoring. Their schools’ core instruction continued during the program. These observational results do not isolate the effect of tutoring or show that contact hours alone caused the differences between groups. The report also notes variability in reading development and subjectivity in tutor-reported participation.

From this program to your readers

Where could stronger
reading support begin?

Start with your students’ reading needs, the instruction already in place, and the time your school can protect for learning.