Skip to main content
← All case studies

Overland Trail Middle School · 2022–24

Overland Trail.
More time to learn.

An earlier launch. More consistent attendance. A school partnership that kept improving. Two years of math tutoring show how the implementation changed alongside student results.

District
Brighton 27J Schools · Colorado
Students & subject
Grades 6–8 · Mathematics
Program format
Live virtual small-group tutoring
Scheduled sessions
Two 40-minute sessions per week

Two-year results

More students showing up.
More time for learning.

The second year paired an earlier start with higher attendance, more tutoring hours, and a larger share of students reaching the program’s growth goal.

Students meeting the growth goal

52.6%

2023–24

2022–2318.4%
2023–2452.6%
+34.2 percentage points

Share reaching the program’s 33% standards-progress goal.

Average student attendance

85.0%

2023–24

2022–2352.5%
2023–2485.0%
+32.5 percentage points

Share of scheduled tutoring sessions attended, on average.

Average tutoring hours

18.4hrs

2023–24

2022–239.6 hrs
2023–2418.4 hrs
+8.8 tutoring hours

Average contact hours per student. Bar scale: 0–20 hours.

These are year-to-year program results, with 49 students enrolled in 2022–23 and 154 in 2023–24. They are not a comparison of one identical student cohort.

Understand the measures

What changed

Build the routine.
Keep learning
from the data.

OTMS kept the same scheduled session format while improving how the program launched and how school teams supported participation.

01

Start earlier.

The first year began in December. The second launched in September, creating a longer window for students to attend sessions and build routines.

02

Make it part of classroom learning.

Teachers reinforced tutoring as part of students’ learning routines. The published case describes a shift toward participation becoming an expectation.

03

Keep a consistent point of contact.

The same school point of contact worked with Cignition across both years, sharing teacher feedback and reviewing the program in brief meetings every two weeks.

87.7%

Met the attendance goal in year two.

The goal was attending at least 70% of scheduled sessions. In year one, 12.2% of students reached it.

The school perspective

Students who see themselves
as mathematicians.

A school leader’s perspective adds context to the program data: students taking ownership of their work and explaining what they understand.

Over the last 2.5 years of working with Cignition, we have had students show significant increases in the mastery of the standards that are a focus for instruction. We continuously look forward to seeing the growth in students over time and working within the classroom with staff and students to push students to own their learning and see themselves as mathematicians.
Christy MeredithAssistant Principal · Overland Trail Middle SchoolSchool partner perspective, as published with this case study.

A lesson inside the data

Starting points
change the picture.

The report found that meeting every engagement benchmark did not automatically mean a larger measured growth score.

Less room to grow can mean a smaller score.

Among year-two students who met all three engagement benchmarks, those who did not reach the academic growth goal began with average mastery scores nearly 2.5 times higher than those who did.

That starting-point difference helps explain why an individual student’s growth score needs to be read alongside their existing understanding.

A measurement finding from this implementation—not a conclusion that engagement does not matter.

Read the evidence

Clear definitions.
A fuller view.

The source report includes the participation data, mastery-check scales, and limitations behind these results.

What does the academic growth goal measure?

The report defines successful academic progress as at least 33% growth across multiple math standards, described as advancing at least one level on the mastery-check rubric. The 18.4% and 52.6% figures are the shares of students who reached that goal. They are not average growth scores or state-test proficiency rates.

Did the mastery-check scale change?

Yes. The 2022–23 scale had three levels; the 2023–24 scale had four. For one comparison, the report combined the middle two levels in the newer scale. It reported standards-progress growth of 19.5% and 44.3% using that aligned scale, and 34.8% for 2023–24 using the original four-point scale. Those growth scores are separate from the share of students meeting the growth goal.

Which engagement benchmarks were used?

The comparison used 70% attendance, 80% tutor-reported participation, and at least 10 contact hours. The report used the same 10-hour threshold in both years to account for the shorter first-year implementation. It was an analysis threshold, rather than a claim that 10 hours is the recommended dosage for every program.

What should readers keep in mind?

This is an observational comparison of two school years, with different enrollment totals and program durations. It does not track one identical student cohort or isolate the effect of any single change. Starting mastery levels also influence how much measurable growth a student can demonstrate.

See the side-by-side program data
Overland Trail Middle School · School-year program comparison
Measure2022–232023–24
Students enrolled49154
Average attendance52.5%85.0%
Students meeting the 70% attendance goal12.2%87.7%
Average tutor-reported participation63.7%74.6%
Students meeting the 80% participation goal20.4%46.1%
Average tutoring contact hours9.618.4
Students meeting the 33% academic growth goal18.4%52.6%

Source: Cignition’s Overland Trail Middle School Program 2022–2024 formal data summary. Participation is tutor-reported; goal-attainment percentages and average measures answer different questions.

From this program to your school

What would a stronger
tutoring routine look like?

Start with your students, your school schedule, and the information your team needs to keep improving.